YouTube begins rolling out a new machine learning system designed to detect and remove fake engagement — including fraudulent likes, comments, and subscriber counts. This follows months of advertiser pressure and public scrutiny about brand safety, authenticity, and the manipulation of platform metrics (YouTube Creator Blog, 2018).
But this isn’t just a creator crackdown. It’s part of a larger pivot by YouTube: tightening eligibility for monetization, restoring advertiser trust, and ensuring real influence isn’t drowned out by bots and engagement pods.
For digital marketers, this changes the rules of video marketing — again. Strategy must now be built for authenticity, not algorithm gaming.
Strategic Insight
What’s your story?
You’re using video to educate, sell, or inspire. Whether you’re running a brand channel or partnering with influencers, your story has to be real. YouTube is cutting through the noise — and punishing manipulation. Your strategy must be built on trust, not tricks.
What do you solve?
You solve the credibility gap. Brands and consumers don’t just want video views — they want signals of real reach and relevance. By avoiding fake engagement tactics and following clear platform guidelines, you preserve access to monetization, visibility, and long-term brand equity.
How do you do it?
- Avoid artificial tactics: Don’t buy subs, participate in engagement groups, or use comment bots. YouTube’s AI is trained to detect patterns across accounts and devices (Google, 2018).
- Create legitimate viewer value: Tutorials, case studies, behind-the-scenes content, and Q&A sessions build true watch time and retention — two of the strongest ranking signals (Backlinko, 2018).
- Leverage metadata and consistency: Titles, descriptions, tags, and playlists matter. So does upload frequency. YouTube rewards structure over stunts.
- Understand monetization rules: As of early 2018, your channel must have 1,000 subscribers and 4,000 hours of watch time in the past 12 months to join the YouTube Partner Program (YouTube Help, 2018). Use this threshold as a quality signal — not just a barrier.
Why do they care?
Because advertisers are watching. YouTube faced an exodus of ad dollars in 2017 after being caught placing ads next to extremist content. Restoring trust means guaranteeing advertisers that creators — and marketers — are playing fair. That means you must play fair too. Real engagement earns ad access. Fake engagement earns penalties.
Monetization and the Enforcement Backdrop
YouTube’s enforcement in June 2018 isn’t random — it’s aligned with several key shifts:
- Adpocalypse fallout (2017–2018): Major brands like AT&T, Verizon, and Pepsi pulled ads after discovering placements next to offensive videos (The Guardian, 2017).
- Revised YouTube Partner Program: Instituted in January 2018, the program raised the bar for monetization, forcing small and mid-tier creators to prove consistent quality before earning ad revenue (YouTube Help, 2018).
- Machine learning moderation: YouTube now uses AI to detect spammy comment patterns, view spikes, and metadata manipulation, flagging or demonetizing offenders (Google AI Blog, 2018).
Marketers using the platform — either through their own content or through influencer partnerships — must now audit for compliance. Partnering with shady creators puts your brand at risk. Promoting content that mimics black hat tactics could lead to account warnings or demonetization.
Fictional Ideas
Tanya runs a wellness brand with a fast-growing YouTube channel. She used to rely on small giveaway loops and comment pods to boost early visibility. But in June 2018, she gets hit with a warning — some of her videos are demonetized due to suspicious engagement spikes.
She pivots.
Instead of boosting fake signals, she:
- Builds a creator collaboration series with 3 other channels in her niche
- Publishes videos that answer subscriber questions directly
- Uses her email list to organically drive traffic to new uploads
- Begins tracking audience retention instead of raw view counts
By the end of the summer, Tanya’s engagement is lower — but real. Her CPM improves, subscriber growth becomes steady, and YouTube restores monetization to all her videos. She doesn’t just adapt — she thrives.
References
- YouTube Creator Blog. (2018). Maintaining trust and preventing abuse on YouTube.
https://youtube-creators.googleblog.com/2018/01/2018-priorities.html - YouTube Help. (2018). Changes to the YouTube Partner Program.
https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/72851 - Google AI Blog. (2018). Using machine learning to improve content moderation.
https://ai.googleblog.com/2018/06/machine-learning-and-moderation.html - The Guardian. (2017). YouTube advertising boycott over hate speech.
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/mar/20/advertisers-boycott-google-youtube - Backlinko. (2018). YouTube Ranking Factors: Complete Study.
https://backlinko.com/youtube-ranking-factors - Marketing Land. (2018). What YouTube’s ad changes mean for marketers.
https://martech.org/youtubes-new-rules-mean-marketers-must-change-how-they-think-about-ads/ - Social Media Examiner. (2018). How to Grow a YouTube Channel Without Breaking the Rules.
https://www.socialmediaexaminer.com/how-to-grow-youtube-channel/ - TubeBuddy Blog. (2018). Avoiding the YouTube Fake Engagement Crackdown.
https://blog.tubebuddy.com/youtube-crackdown-2018/
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.