YouTube recently began purging fake engagement — including likes, comments, and subscribers — to clean up the platform and rebuild trust. Shortly after, both Twitter and Facebook followed suit with sweeping actions of their own.
- Twitter deleted millions of suspicious and locked accounts to reduce follower fraud and spam (Twitter Blog, 2018).
- Facebook accelerated enforcement on fake Page administrators and began requiring verification for Pages with large U.S. audiences (Facebook Newsroom, 2018).
This isn’t a coincidence — it’s a coordinated shift across the social landscape: authenticity is no longer optional. For digital marketers, the era of “growth at any cost” is giving way to accountability, transparency, and earned influence.
Strategic Insight
What’s your story?
You’re building a digital presence that reflects real people, real ideas, and real trust. But inflated numbers and anonymous Pages are liabilities. Your story must evolve from follower counts and content volume to credibility and connection.
What do you solve?
You solve platform fatigue. Audiences are overwhelmed by inauthentic voices. Algorithms are trying to protect them. Marketers can solve this by building real, engaged followings, vetting collaborators, and following platform identity standards.
How do you do it?
- Audit your presence: Use tools like Twitter Audit, CrowdTangle, and Facebook Page Transparency to review follower quality and admin authenticity.
- Prioritize identity: Facebook now requires Page admins for large U.S. audiences to complete a two-factor authentication and location check. Complete this process early to avoid disruptions (Facebook Newsroom, 2018).
- Engage over inflate: Ask questions, respond to comments, and create content that sparks dialogue. The more real your engagement, the less dependent you are on superficial growth hacks.
- Be cautious with influencer marketing: Twitter purges revealed that some influencers had bought fake followers for years. Work only with verified creators who maintain high engagement-to-follower ratios (Socialbakers, 2018).
Why do they care?
Because trust drives results. Brands and platforms alike are being held accountable for what appears on their feeds. Fake engagement isn’t just a bad look — it’s a measurable risk. Playing fair now builds the credibility and continuity that unstable accounts can’t fake.
A Platform-Wide Trend
Major platforms are stepping up enforcement. Here’s how each one is cracking down — and what it means for marketers:
YouTube
- Focus of Enforcement: Fake likes, comments, subscribers
- Marketer Impact: Risk of demonetization and algorithmic suppression
- Focus of Enforcement: Locked and bot accounts purged
- Marketer Impact: Sudden drop in follower counts; increase in transparency
- Focus of Enforcement: Page admin identity checks; fake admins removed
- Marketer Impact: Verified admins now required for major Pages; greater scrutiny of political or issue-based content
What started as a response to brand safety is now evolving into a full-blown social sanitization strategy — and marketers must adapt or risk losing reach, access, or legitimacy.
Fictional Ideas
Jordan runs digital strategy for a non-profit focused on urban education. Their Facebook Page has grown quickly — but the team used freelance help and wasn’t monitoring who had admin access.
Eventually, Facebook flags their Page for incomplete admin verification. The Page becomes temporarily unpublished. Jordan scrambles to verify all U.S. admins, remove inactive users, and complete Facebook’s new two-step process. Meanwhile, their Twitter account drops 6% in followers — many of them inactive or spam accounts.
Jordan learns the hard way: numbers aren’t everything. They rebuild their Page structure, create a transparency policy for their social team, and focus future campaigns on comments, not just reach. Over time, they regain visibility — this time, built on verified credibility.
References
- Twitter Blog. (2018). Confidence in follower counts.
https://blog.twitter.com/official/en_us/topics/company/2018/Confidence-in-Follower-Counts.html - Facebook Newsroom. (2018). Increasing transparency for Pages.
https://about.fb.com/news/2018/07/increased-authenticity-for-pages/ - YouTube Creator Blog. (2018). Maintaining trust and preventing abuse on YouTube.
https://youtube-creators.googleblog.com/2018/01/2018-priorities.html - Google AI Blog. (2018). Machine learning moderation for fake engagement.
https://ai.googleblog.com/2018/06/machine-learning-and-moderation.html - Socialbakers. (2018). The truth about influencer marketing and fake followers.
https://www.socialbakers.com/blog/influencer-marketing-and-fake-followers - TechCrunch. (2018). Twitter follower counts drop as part of crackdown on fake accounts.
https://techcrunch.com/2018/07/12/twitter-cracks-down-on-fake-accounts/ - The Verge. (2018). Facebook now requires Page admins to prove their identity.
https://www.theverge.com/2018/7/10/17555250/facebook-page-admin-authenticity-verification - eMarketer. (2018). Social platforms boost transparency to restore trust.
https://www.emarketer.com/content/social-media-platforms-boost-transparency
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.